[Peter]
How can it be
Really you and me?
My head is spinning sideways!
If I'm dreaming, leave me here
To live in your bed a minute
Like this!
Like this!
It's Christmas on a birthday!
The wish I never thought I'd get was in this kiss
A week ago this'd never happen
Cut to now, and I've seen ya naked!
Wildest dreams, I couldn't conceive
It's such a scandal!

Look at you, you quarter-something
Look at me, I'm at best a mascot
Look at us, who would believe

You and I are so alive
Just in this moment
Never thought it could be like this
Who would've thought I would find
You!
I'm falling!
So freely!
Into you and really
All that I want is
Forever you & I

[Peter, spoken]
Oh! Mrs. McConnell! I didn't see ya there. Might I say, I love your linens, while frankly disagreeing with your decorating scheme. Oh, why am I wearing your son's jacket? Well, here's the thing Mrs. M... Your son is a homosexual. I was as surprised as you are! But, uh, he digs guys. He's a guy-digger. And I am the guy he happens to dig. Is it because my penis is bigger than his? Your guess is as good as mine

[Jason, spoken]
Who are you talking to?

[Peter, spoken]
Nobody!

[Peter, sung]
Could it be?
Just by gravity
The world has broken open!
Up is down and left is right
We're shattering laws of physics!
I'm gay!
You're gay!
I wish I'd known this last year
Headed toward the end
We could go all the way!

A week ago, you were just a stranger

[Jason, sung]
Cut to now, and I'm in your t-shirt!

[Peter]
Take that off, you're stretching it out

[Jason]
You're such an asshole!

[Both]
I just knew
When I looked at you
That this would be what I really needed

[Jason]
Don't look down
Hang on to me

[Both]
You and I
I'm so alive!
Just in this moment
Never thought it could be like this
I never thought I would find
You!
I'm falling!
So freely
Into you and really
All that I want is...