[Verse 1]
Do you still have the CDs that I burned you?
The T-Shirt you pulled off me the night you said you loved me?
I still have the marks that you made on me
It's easy to forget that you are gone

[Pre-Chorus]
I talk about the past like I talk about you
I leave out every little thing that I don't like remembering
I miss you more than I say I do
You had to follow all your dreams, move to New York away from me

[Chorus]
You were so easy to forgive, but not so easy to forget
Why can't I keep you right where I want you? (Ooh)
And even though you put an ocean in between us
I will try to keep us

[Post-Chorus]
Together, forever, nostalgia
It's crazy, baby, I want you

[Verse 2]
I just need to know that you are happy
So, if it couldn't be me, then, go ahead, forget me
I traced my steps back to where we first met
And hold the memory till you slip away
[Pre-Chorus]
I talk about the past like I talk about you
I leave out every little thing that I don't like remembering
I miss you more than I say I do
You had to follow all your dreams, just wish that they included me

[Chorus]
You were so easy to forgive, but not so easy to forget
Why can't I keep you right where I want you? (Ooh)
And even though you put an ocean in between us
I will try to keep us

[Post-Chorus]
Together, forever, nostalgia
It's crazy, baby, I want you
Together, forever, nostalgia
It's crazy, baby, I want you
Together, forever, nostalgia
It's crazy, baby, I want you
Together, forever, nostalgia
It's crazy, baby, I want you