[Verse 1: Anderson]
I did my time, I paid my price
For all these things I did
I lost my feet, you said your piece
I thought that that was it
So when you sleep so peacefully
And all your sins are buried deep
While you're dreaming, I'm outside
Digging up the ones I missed

[Chorus: Anderson and McFarland]
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around again?
I don't ever know
When's it coming back again?
You can try all you want
But the past knows what you did
And I can't seem to get away from it
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around
Baby, coming back around again?

[Verse 2: Anderson]
I've been chewed up, I've been spit out
But never thought to quit
I've taken blows and felt them all
Nothing close to this
So when you sleep so peacefully
And all your sins are buried deep
While you're dreaming I'm outside
Digging up the ones I missed
[Chorus: Anderson and McFarland]
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around again?
I don't ever know
When's it coming back again?
You can try all you want
But the past knows what you did
And I can't seem to get away from it
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around
Baby, coming back around again?

[Bridge: Anderson]
My back's against the wall
I'm feeling for the door
But I can't find it as the knife slides into me
And as I'm standing there, oh she walks in
And blurry fears are coming clear
And I can finally see

[Chorus: Anderson and McFarland]
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around again?
I don't ever know
When's it coming back again?
You can try all you want
But the past knows what you did
And I can't seem to get away from it
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around
Baby, coming back around again?
[Outro]
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around again? (When's it coming back?)
When's it coming back again? (Ooh)
And I can't seem to get away from it
When's it coming back again?
When's it coming back around
Baby, coming back around?
When's it coming back around
Baby, coming back around again?