[Verse 1]
Beautiful, she looks just the way that I thought she would
And it seems like you did just as I said you should
Forget me, find somebody who does you good

[Verse 2]
She's Cinderella, I'm like the carriage
She brought the threads and I came with baggage
I heard she's fixing all of the damage
Yeah, this one's a keeper, she fits the shoe
Glad my mistakes could bring her to you
Seem so happy, fucking fantastic, but

[Chorus]
Why must she be beautiful?
Oh, why must she be beautiful?
You found what you needed, I can deal with that
But seeing you together is like a heart attack
Why must she be beautiful?

[Verse 3]
Usual, typical of me to push away like that
Uglier each time that I come running back
God knows I don't get attached, get attached
I was a charmer
I lost my magic
I put my guard up
Default to habit
You know she's fixing all of the damage
This one's a keeper, she fits the shoe
Glad my mistakes could bring her to you
Seem so happy, fucking fantastic, but
[Chorus]
Why must she be beautiful?
Oh, why must she be beautiful?
You found what you needed, I can deal with that
But seeing you together is like a heart attack
Oh, why must she be beautiful?

[Verse 4]
I watch you from outside the window
And I can't stop even though I know
It's not my business where you put your heart, now
I witness the way she moves
And can't help but love her for you
You earned it
I'm glad she's perfect, but

[Chorus]
Why must she be beautiful?
Oh, why must she be beautiful?
Oh, you found what you needed, I can deal with that
But seeing you together is like a heart attack
Why must she be beautiful?