[Verse 1]
Wish I could live instead, in 1972
Sometime, sometime
Before the internet and all it's traces of you
So I, so I
Won't have a phone with cracks that you
Pour through every time I'm on my own
And I never notice
That you found someone else
But let me ask now I do

[Chorus]
Does he make you happy?
I heard he's an athlete, a hit with your family
So what do I, what do I do?
I'm more of a black sheep
The last one your dad meets before you get married
So what do I, what do I do?
He brings you coffee in bed, reads all the books that you read
I bet you love him to death
So what do I, what do I do?
Now I'm just an "oh well", a story you don't tell
But you're still my whole world
So what do I, what do I do?

[Verse 2]
It's all the little things he gets to love about you
The way that you laugh when no one's around to hear it
Still see your fingerprints pressed on me like a tattoo
But they're someone else's now
[Chorus]
Does he make you happy?
I heard he's an athlete, a hit with your family
So what do I, what do I do?
I'm more of a black sheep
The last one your dad meets before you get married
So what do I, what do I do?
He brings you coffee in bed, reads all the books that you read
I bet you love him to death
So what do I, what do I do?
Now I'm just an "oh well", a story you don't tell
But you're still my whole world
So what do I, what do I-

[Bridge]
So, what the hell am I supposed to do (Ahh-ahh-ahh)
When I can't find my heart because it's lost on you? (Ohh-ohh-ohh)
Oh, what the hell am I supposed to say (Ahh-ahh-ahh)
When I can't catch my breath because you took it away? (Ohh-ohh-ohh)

[Chorus]
Does he make you happy?
I heard he's an athlete, a hit with your family
So what do I, what do I do?
I'm more of a black sheep
The last one your dad meets before you get married
So what do I, what do I do?
He brings you coffee in bed, reads all the books that you read
I bet you love him to death
So what do I, what do I do?
Now I'm just an "oh well", a story you don't tell
But you're still my whole world
So what do I, what do I do?