[Verse 1]
We should've been good, we should've behaved, we should've been smarter
I thought we could be friends, it was easier then, but now I'm finding it harder
We should've been through, but we messed it up
'Cause one night with you wasn't quite enough
This isn't the end, I gotta see you again, you wanna go for another?

[Chorus]
All our friends say that we're tempting fate
It's a bad idea, it's a big mistake
'Cause I don't love you
No, I don't love you
Gonna do this, it's so wrong, I know
Wanna hold you for a second, then I'm letting you go
'Cause I don't love you
I don't love you

[Post-Chorus]
Gonna meet you in the city in the dead of the night
My God you look so pretty, wanna go for a ride?
I'll kiss you in a minute, then we'll say our goodbyes
'Cause I don't love you
I can take to you to corner of the 74'
My God, I get a feelin' that we've done this before
When we're wakin' up tomorrow it will be nothing more
'Cause I don't love you
[Verse 2]
We should've been good, we should've behaved, we should've known better
But just for tonight, we can pretend, that we're together
We'll cross the line way after dark
'Cause there was a time when we had a spark
This isn't the end, I gotta see you again, but nothing's forever

[Chorus]
All our friends say that we're tempting fate
It's a bad idea, it's a big mistake
'Cause I don't love you
I don't love you
Gonna do this, it's so wrong, I know
Wanna hold you for a second, then I'm letting you go
'Cause I don't love you
I don’t love you

[Post-Chorus]
Gonna meet you in the city in the dead of the night
My God, you look so pretty, wanna go for a ride?
I'll kiss you in a minute, then we'll say our goodbyes
'Cause I don't love you
I can take to you to corner of the 74'
My God, I get a feelin' that we've done this before
When we're wakin' up tomorrow it will be nothing more
'Cause I don't love you
[Outro]
All our friends say that we're tempting fate
'Cause I don't love you
No, I don't love you