[Intro (Simon Smoke, Baba Chops)]
I dunno about you, Baba
But I'm done with all this Smiling Critters stuff
It's time for some Nightmare Critter chaos

[Verse 1 (Simon Smoke, Poe, Baba Chops)]
N-A-G-H-T-M-A-R-E, keep you company
We'll shock you and we'll haunt you in your dreams
When you go to sleep
N-I-G-H-T-M-A-R-E, antithesis
The better, bolder bad guys gonna bring
Negativity
I alone don't really care if it's been a while
We'll show you how to really play
With no need to smile

[Chorus (Nightmare Critters, Allister Gator)]
S-C-A-R-E every night, you and me
S-C-A-R-E, no more rules, just anarchy
S-C-A-R-E every night, you and me
S-C-A-R-E, Nightmare Critters make you scream

[Bridge (Rabie Baby)]
So, you might know Nightmare Critters are the best
But you don't know all their secrеts, do you?
Badabada black sheep, Baba Chops
Beat it, back up, better yеt get lost
Icky Licky lost the race
He'll tell you that's not the case
Allister's a lazy guy, he'll be waiting 'til he dies
Simon?
Yeah?
He's infamous, but he can always sit with us
Touille says random junk (Quoi?)
Poe's in an emo funk (Hey)
Maggie's munching all the sweets
Want some tea? Then come to me
[Chorus (Nightmare Critters, Baba Chops, Touille, Maggie Mako)]
S-C-A-R-E every night, you and me
S-C-A-R-E, smiling's too much energy
S-C-A-R-E every night, you and me
S-C-A-R-E one more time and make it mean
S-C-A-R-E every night, you and me
S-C-A-R-E, we'll be haunting all your dreams
S-C-A-R-E every night, you and me
S-C-A-R-E, Nightmare Critters make you scream (Hahaha)