[Intro: The Doctor]
You've made a grave mistake
While you all were above, smiling in the Playcare
Everyone forgot about my new puppets down below

[Verse 1: Maggie Mako]
Don't you run away, my dear
We love to see you shake with fear
So long happy, so long cheer
We'll show you all your greatest fears

[Chorus: Baba Chops, Rabie Baby, Simon Smoke, Poe]
You should be much more than wary
Nightmare Critters, extra scary
Darker here than what you once knew
You'd be lucky if we killed you
Hey, what's wrong? Just wanna play
Not asking you to stay, no chance to run away
Before you meet the еnd
You should be much more than wary
Nightmare Crittеrs, extra scary

[Post-Chorus: Simon Smoke, Maggie Mako, Rabie Baby]
Ha, you think that purple reject is scary?
We're gonna really haunt your dreams
And tell them why, Sparky
Yeah?
[Verse 2: Simon, Nightmare Critters]
We're chill, and they talk too much
Hot, and they know they're not
Bad, at best they're mild
Tough, they fake their smiles
And if you know, you know
If you know you know
We've got it all, down low
Down in the Playtime Co

[Bridge: Catnap, Simon Smoke]
Hi, hello, it's been a while
Since I've had a happy smile
I'm so glad that I can be
Part of Smiling Critters team
Wait this isn't right at all
I'm not cute and I'm too tall
Nothing else is out there
I only make nightmares
Hi

[Chorus: Touille, Poe, Baba Chops, Maggie Mako]
You should be much more than wary
Nightmare Critters, extra scary
Darker here than what you once knew
You'd be lucky if we killed you
Hey, what's wrong? Just wanna play
Not asking you to stay, no chance to run away
Before you meet the end
You should be much more than wary
Nightmare Critters, extra scary