[Verse 1: William Afton/Springtrap]
I was lost and was afraid
I believed all of their lies
I believed that I was safe
And that I would never die
Now I'm all alone
I've been hiding in the dark
I just want to go home
But my deeds sent me too far

[Chorus: All Aftons]
All stay strong, we live eternally!
All is well in the Afton family!
Lives, they fell to pure insanity!
All is hell in the Afton family!

[Verse 2: ??? Afton/Bite of '83 Victim]
I never did go near
'Cuz I know just what I saw
Yet on a day of joy
My life ended to their flaws!
Now I'm all alone
Fighting monsters in the dark
I wish that I could live
But I fear I've gone too far!
[Chorus: All Aftons]
All stay strong, we live eternally!
All is well in the Afton family!
Lives, they fell to pure insanity!
All is hell in the Afton family!

[Verse 3: Elizabeth Afton/Circus Baby]
I often do pretend
Can't you see I'm broken down?
I wish this were the end
But continue on I vow
Now I'm all alone
I'm still hiding in the dark
As saddened souls we roam
We can only go so far!

[Chorus: All Aftons]
All stay strong, we live eternally!
All is well in the Afton family!
Lives, they fell to pure insanity!
All is hell in the Afton family!

[Verse 4: Michael Afton/Ennard] [?]
Always begging, please
Yet the outcome I would dread
I've fallen to my knees
Let my pride get to my head
Now I'm all alone
Hearing whispers in the dark
I wander through the past
Seeing memories afar
[Chorus: All Aftons]
All stay strong, we live eternally!
All is well in the Afton family!
Lives, they fell to pure insanity!
All is hell in the Afton family!