[Verse 1]
You wonder why I showed up at your house tonight
Don't look surprised, 'cause you know everything I like
Let's go inside, remind me how you figured me out
And in, and out
Curious, until you came and taught me how
Hurry up, I'm ready for my lesson now
'Cause you're the one that I remember breaking me up
And down, and up

[Pre-Chorus]
I even told my momma
That there would be another you
I can't believe I'm still a sucker
After all this time

[Chorus]
You really were my first lovе
Could feel it every time wе touched
You and me, we used to do
All the things we never knew
You really messed my head up
And even after we broke up
I had a boyfriend or two
But I cheated on 'em all, with you
You really were my first love
[Verse 2]
I must admit that I could go for some of that
I won't forget, 'cause you're the best I've ever had
I can't resist, you work it from the front to the back
To front, to back
I can't explain, I knew it from the day we met
It's still the same feeling that I used to get
I love the way you take me from the floor to the bed
To floor, to bed

[Pre-Chorus]
I even told my momma
That there would be another you
I can't believe I'm still a sucker
After all this time

[Chorus]
You really were my first love
Could feel it every time we touched
You and me, we used to do
All the things we never knew
You really messed my head up
And even after we broke up
I had a boyfriend or two
But I cheated on 'em all, with you
You really were my first love
[Pre-Chorus]
I even told my momma
That there would be another you
I can't believe I'm still a sucker
After all this time

[Chorus]
You really were my first love (My first love)
Could feel it every time we touched (Time we touched)
You and me, we used to do (Used to do)
All the things we never knew (Never knew)
You really messed my head up (My head up)
And even after we broke up (We broke up)
I had a boyfriend or two (Or two)
But I cheated on 'em all, with you (With you)
You really were my first love (My first love)