[Verse 1: Peder Elias]
I wish that I had stayed inside
And not got that coffee at eight-o-five
'Cause if I did, then I wouldn't have seen you
There with someone that I've never known
And lookin' and know you look beautiful
Don't wanna care, but I still do

[Pre-Chorus: Peder Elias]
'Cause you were my first, you were my last
You were my future, but now you're my past
And I just can't let go

[Chorus: Peder Elias, Paige]
I don't wanna see you two laughing at a party
Doing things that we used to do
While I'm here with somebody doing nothing
But wishing that she was you
It's not that I'm hoping, you're not happy
Baby, I do, but
I'm not ready to see you at parties with somebody new
When I'm still getting over you

[Verse 2: Paige]
I'm staring at a photograph
I'd lie if I said I don't want you back
Now you and I'vе become nothing but strangers
I'm with somеone 'cause I don't want
To show you it hurts me like hell you're gone
Don't wanna care, but I still do
[Pre-Chorus: Paige]
'Cause you were my first, you were my last
You were my future, but now you're my past
And I just can't let go

[Chorus: Peder Elias, Paige]
I don't wanna see you two laughing at a party
Doing things that we used to do
While I'm here with somebody doing nothing
But wishing that she was you
It's not that I'm hoping, you're not happy
Baby, I do, but
I'm not ready to see you at parties with somebody new
When I'm still getting over you
When I'm still getting over you

[Instrumental Break]

[Chorus: Peder Elias, Paige]
I don't wanna see you two laughing at a party
Doing things that we used to do
While I'm here with somebody doing nothing
But wishing that she was you
It's not that I'm hoping, you're not happy
Baby, I do, but
I'm not ready to see you at parties with somebody new
When I'm still getting over you