Will I ever know what we could have had?
Breaks my heart to know
That you're no longer mine

You should have stayed
It would have been okay

Will I ever know where we would be now?
Sometimes I still wanna call you
Just to say goodnight

You should have stayed
Oh, it would have been okay
You should have stayed
It would have been okay

Why did you go?
I'll always wonder
'Cause every day I think of you and me
Oh, I should have told you

That you should have stayed
It would have been okay
Oh, You should have stayed
It would have been okay