I always knew you were a little bit bloodless
And you could turn unsentimental as a mannequin
Leaving fools like me, reasoning with plastic
Fools like me, rereading your last letter
Fools like me, thinking I should’ve known better than this

I always knew you had a catacombs in you
And when times got tough, that’s where you’d descend to
Leaving fools like me, up here on the surface
Kicking myself, knowing I deserved it
I’d seen it beforе, and still I couldn’t resist

I always knew you had a heart with a trapdoor
Any momеnt, at your word, I could fall through the floorboards
Because I liked you just a little too much
And I had too much time, and you didn’t have enough
And you just changed your mind, all that’s fair in war and love

But it was what I didn’t know that got me
Your warm, tender love that shocked me
This isn’t what I expected
Didn’t think you would kiss like this
I never took you for a handholder