[Verse 1]
I can just tell, know this story so well
I just can't get her out of my head
The back of that cab when I never had
A reason to go where she led
So where was this going, and all the while knowing
That I'd catch a plane either way
But maybe tonight if I played my cards right
I'd find a reason to stay

[Hook]
She's in New York and I'm in the deep blue sea
She's just a dream and that's all that she can be for me

[Verse 2]
I'm taking this slowly, but I'm feeling lonely
And I hope she is feeling it too
Closing my eyes I remember that night
And the rhythm that we fell into
If everyone else in that city had left
I wouldn't have known for awhile
Yeah I'd still be sitting there, stuck in the moment where
She leaned in to give me a smile

[Hook]
She's in New York and I'm in the deep blue sea
She's just a dream and that's all that she can be for me

[Bridge]
And I'm sinking, I'm sinking
In the deep blue sea
I'm sinking, I'm sinking
In the deep blue sea

[Hook]
She's in New York and I'm in the deep blue sea
She's just a dream, does she think of me
She's in New York and I'm in the deep blue sea
She's just a dream and so I guess I'll just sleep