[Verse 1]
Shut you out my mind
Put it all behind me
But I'm alone tonight
Run my fingers through the phone book
Like we're in the 90s
'Cause as soon as I leave you, I miss you
I can't explain
Why I came to this bar just to kiss you
Feeling this way

[Chorus]
Too supernatural to be casual
I lie, la la la la lie
When I tell myself I want someone else
But I run to you every time
And we both know it's no fair, no fair
And we both know it's going there
Supernatural

[Verse 2]
You wanna come upstairs
It's good until it scares you
You act like you don't care
Tell me all about what I don't wanna hear about
Other girls 'cause you need a distraction
You can't explain
Why you say that we're done, then it happens
Always this way

[Chorus]
It's too supernatural to be casual
I lie, la la la la lie
When I tell myself I want someone else
But I run to you every time
And we both know it's no fair, no fair
And we both know it's going there
Supernatural

[Post-Chorus]
You want me, I want you
We fall, then we fall through
You hurt me, I hurt you
I leave you, I miss you
We fall, then we fall through
But as soon as I leave you I miss you

[Chorus]
It's too supernatural to be casual
I lie, la la la la lie
When I tell myself I want someone else
But I run to you every time
And we both know it's no fair, no fair
And we both know it's going there
Supernatural
Supernatural

[Post-Chorus]
You want me, I want you
We fall, then we fall through
You hurt me, I hurt you
I leave you, I miss you
We fall, then we fall through
You hurt me, I hurt you
I leave you, I miss you