[Verse 1]
I sat outside your house today, just thinkin' you never hurt
It's like the time I packed your things and dropped them off where you work
I know you love to wash your car, so I left it in the lake
They say the strongest part of love is called hate

[Pre-Chorus 1]
Do you feel like I should sit around with your touch
And your smell on my couch, and your hair in my brush?
I loved you too much, oh
Do you think that I should move along, change my phone, get it on?
I'll be gone, treat him wrong till the day
That someone loves me the same way

[Chorus]
How am I supposed to feel? (Oh)
What exactly should I do?
I know you're no good for me
Yet and still, I'm lovin' you
I must like these lonely nights
Beggin' you to do me right
This time, I just don't know
Heart says stay, mind says go

[Verse 2]
I knew I heard it in your voice, something was wrong with the day
I feel I didn't have the choice, my heart was not in the way
Found out that I'm up in the cut, some chick was wearing my face
You're lucky I'm in a good mood or she'll lay
[Pre-Chorus 2]
Do you know how it feels sittin' round, smellin' sheets, feelin' down?
Catchin' heat from my friends where you've been?
Out with her again
Do you think that it's cool to act the fool inside my house?
I put you out, you come back in, we fight again, nobody wins
And baby, you should know that this is it

[Chorus]
How am I supposed to feel? (How am I supposed to feel?)
What exactly should I do?
I know you're no good for me
Yet and still, I'm lovin' you (I'm lovin' you, yeah, yeah)
I must like these lonely nights
Beggin' you to do me right
This time, I just don't know (I just don't know)
Heart says stay, mind says go (How am I supposed to feel?)
How am I supposed to feel?
What exactly should I do? (Oh)
I know you're no good for me
Yet and still, I'm lovin' you
I must like these lonely nights
Beggin' you to do me right
This time (Oh), I just don't know
Heart says stay, mind says go (My mind says go)
[Break]
Oh, oh
Hey, ooh, yeah
Ooh, ooh
Oh!

[Bridge]
Sometimes, you can't let go (Can't let go)
Even your heart says so (Heart says so)
I have to let you see (Let you see)
Your love could never be (Oh, never be)
Real love with me, you see (Oh, no)
Can't let you just dog me (Just dog me)
I tried to love you still (Oh, no)
I now know how it feels (I know how it feels)

[Chorus]
How am I supposed to feel? (Oh)
What exactly should I do? (Should I do)
I know you're no good for me
Yet and still, I'm lovin' you
I must like these lonely nights
Beggin' you to do me right
This time, I just don't know (Oh, this time)
Heart says stay, mind says go (My mind says go)
How am I supposed to feel? (Oh)
What exactly should I do? (Should I do, yeah)
I know you're no good for me
Yet and still, I'm lovin' you
I must like these lonely nights
Beggin' you to do me right
This time, I just don't know
Heart says stay (Oh), mind says go
How am I supposed to feel? (Go, go, go)
It says go, go, go
I know you're no good for me (Oh, oh, oh)
Go, go, go, go
I must like these lonely nights (Go, go, go)
Beggin' you to do me right
This time, I just don't know
Heart says stay, mind says go (Oh, I gotta go)
How am I supposed to feel?
What exactly should I do? (No, no)
I know you're no good for me
Yet and still, I'm lovin' you
I must like these lonely nights
Beggin' you to do me right
This time, I just don't know
Heart says stay (Heart says), mind says go