She said, "I think I like girls"
I said, "I do too."
She said, "I'm so afraid 'cause I'm still in love
Still in love with you."

So we cried all night
And then we cried all year
I said, "You're the only one who could ever dry
Ever dry my tears."

Sometimes all you've got is too much
Sometimes nothing's ever enough
Even the best stories wrap up
But I still believe there's gotta be a sequel to us

(No, oh, don't go. No, oh, don't go.)

I said
"I'm leavin' town"
She said, "I think you should,"
"It's probably for the better but it's maybe not
Maybe not for good"
So we drove all night
A million miles at least
And when we hit the coast
She put herself on a redeye flight back east

Sometimes all you've got is too much
Sometimes nothing's ever enough
Even the best stories wrap up
But I still believe there's gotta be a sequel to us

(No, oh, don't go. No, oh, don't go.)
(Don't say never, we'll stay together.)

I said, "I miss your face."
"When ya comin' back?"
"My faith is shaken."
"But you left my heart intact!"

Sometimes all you've got is too much
Sometimes nothing's ever enough
Even the best stories wrap up
But I still believe there's gotta be a sequel to us

(No, oh, don't go. No, oh, don't go.)
(Don't say never, we'll stay together.)