[Verse 1]
I watched my heart trapezing to the water
I clapped my hands as you were taking a bow
I sat and watched you leaving for an hour
I still can’t believe it now, oh

[Chorus 1]
We could have gone the other way
I could have been the one to make you stay
Woah-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh-oh
I thought it would be you and I
We could have had a life supply
We could have hit the bullseye
Woah-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh-oh
We could have hit the bullseye

[Verse 2]
I saw my brother standing at the altar
I thought at you as they were taking their vows
I sat and watched this picture for an hour
I still believe somehow, oh

[Chorus 1]
We could have gone the other way
I could have been the one to make you stay
Woah-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh-oh
I thought it would be you and I
We could have had a life supply
We could have hit the bullseye
Woah-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh-oh
We could have hit the bullseye
[Interlude]
Bullseye...
Bullseye...

[Bridge]
I could give you what you wanted
You never told me what you needed
I could give you what you wanted
Tell me what you need, tell me what you need

[Chorus 2]
Cause it could have gone the other way
I could have been the one to make you stay
Woah-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh-oh
Could have hit the bullseye
And I wish I was the other guy
I wish I was the one to make you cry
Woah-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh-oh
Or could have hit the bullseye
And we could have had a life supply
We could have hit the bullseye
Woah-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh-oh, don't you know?
Could have hit the bullseye
And, and, could have hit the bullseye