[Verse 1]
Raised in the first pew, praises for Yeshua
Case of a small town repression
Your body was baptized, so disenfranchised
I was your favorite confession
My past was checkered
Your spotless record was probably in jeopardy
Your place or my place
His grace and your grace felt like the same thing to me

[Chorus]
I never felt like I was sinning with you
Always felt like I could talk to God in the morning
I knew that I would end up with you
Always felt like I could talk to God in the morning
If it's so wrong, why did it feel so right?
If it’s so wrong, why'd it never feel like sinning with you?
Sinning with you

[Post-Chorus]
Yeah, yeah, yeah

[Verse 2]
I felt closer to the stars with you
I felt forgiveness in my heart with you
Saw the light in the dark with you
Felt like I could fly
Take me down where the river is
Pull me under in your innocence
I wasn't in it for the hell of it
I guess that’s why
[Chorus]
I never felt like I was sinning with you
Always felt like I could talk to God in the morning
I knew that I would end up with you
Always felt like I could talk to God in the morning
If it's so wrong, why did it feel so right?
If it's so wrong, why'd it never feel like sinning with you?
Sinning with you

[Bridge]
I hate it when I can't feel the Holy Spirit
I know what it feels like crossin' the line
But I never felt shame, never felt sorry
Never felt guilty touching your body
As long as you're for me, as long as I'm for you
Who could be against us, baby?

[Outro]
(Ooh, ooh)
If it’s so wrong, why did it feel so right?
If it’s so wrong, why'd it never feel like sinning with you?
Sinning with you