[Verse 1]
You said it’s so easy
To fall, to yearn
Not sure what you see in me
Said it's a lovely
Thought, hope
A wonderful possibility
Said we could go there
Run, play
There’s so much to share
God it’s so unfair
Waiting, wishing
For them to answer my prayer

[Chorus]
Just when I thought it was safe
My heart finds a new way to break
Just thought when I thought I'd be fine
You sneak back into my mind

[Verse 2]
No compass, no raft
Adrift, astray
No way of going back
Gasping for air
Stranded, drowning
Basking in despair
You could throw me a line
And you do
You show you care, every time
And that's why it hurts
Whining, pining
Won't you lift this curse?
[Chorus]
Just when I thought it was safe
My heart finds a new way to break
Just when I thought I'd be fine
You sneak back into my mind

[Bridge]
Just when I thought it was safe
Just when I thought it was safe
Just when I thought it was safe
Just when I thought it was safe

[Chorus]
My heart finds a new way to break
Just when I thought I'd be fine
You sneak back into my mind
My heart finds a new way to break
Just when I thought I'd be fine
You sneak back into my mind
Oh, oh