[Verse 1]
A single working taillight on the trailer that she rented
Slowly disappeared around the bend
And I stood there in silence, wondering where she might be headed
As a chapter from my life came to an end

[Chorus]
I was so sure I'd found the right one
I took my heart out on a limb
I know she really tried to love me
But she never really got over him

[Verse 2]
She told me when I met her about all those painful memories
The way that love treated her before
How she gave her heart to someone, believing in forever
Just to see it carried out the door

[Chorus]
Still, I believed that this was something
That a little love and time would surely mend
And I gave her everything I could have
But she never really got over him

[Bridge]
First loves die hard
You just can't erase the past
When every emotion brings back memories of him
Now how can I compete with that
[Chorus]
Well, I haven't heard about her lately
But I think about her now and then
And it's a shame but I'd be willing to bet
That she never really got over him
You know I never really got over her
And she never really got over him