[Verse 1]
I guess she's just not that into it
Always on her phone, but she’s never texting me
I don't know why I thought it would be different
At least I got that shirt for her for free
She'll probably call me in a day or two
Asking where I’ve been, haven't talked to her for days
She probably thinks I've moved onto someone new
And now she'll have a million things to say

[Pre-Chorus]
And she'll admit that she's been distant
Her feelings for me inconsistent
And I'll admit that I'm not okay

[Chorus]
I’m thinking back on all of the times
I didn’t wanna put this thing on the shelf
But now I'm thinking that it might just be wise to go
And get ignored by somebody else

[Verse 2]
It’s funny how things are better now (Hey)
Finally got something besides her on my mind
And isn't it kinda crazy how
Without her, my life seems to be just fine (Hey)
You were hoping I would come back to you
Thought I'd be waiting for a chance to try again (Hey)
Well, sorry girl, but I've got some things to do
Besides, I don’t even want to win
[Chorus]
I start thinking back on all of the times
I didn't wanna put this thing on the shelf
But now I haven't, girl, well, I'm not surprised
That you're already fooling somebody else

[Outro]
Thinking back on all of the times
I didn't wanna put this thing on the shelf (Woo)