[Intro: Amanda Fagan]
I still remember
The snow last December
The way it fell on the ground
In this miserable place
With you I felt safe
I thought that on you I could count

[Verse 1: Amanda Fagan]
I remember last Christmas
You got me a new disc
I was so excited to put it on
And we danced along
To my favorite song
I can't believe those days are gone
How did such a happy story
Have such a tragic end

[Chorus: Amanda Fagan]
Could we go back to how it was back then
When nothing mattered more than friends
Before wе lost that happiness
To stubbornness and arrogance

[Verse 2: ButterscotchBread]
I still rеmember the lingering embers
You stared at in my fireplace
I let you borrow my things
Took you under my wing
But I guess that my trust was misplaced
I put my guard down just for you
I should have known you'd leave me too
[Chorus: ButterscotchBread & Amanda Fagan, ButterscotchBread]
(But) could we go back to how it was back then
When nothing mattered more than friends
Before we lost that happiness
To selfishness and impudence

[Verse 3: Mizz Fish]
You needed me last December
But I was still in November
Focusing only on my regrets
And I let everything that we had
Slip right through my hands
Am I the reason
That such a happy story had such a tragic end

[Verse 4: Seiggel]
I guess I showed up
A little too late
Would things have been different
If I had stayed
I can hardly remember
The rain last December
But I know it that burned through my skin
They all loved that version of me
The one who couldn't think
Would you love me more
If I was who I was then
[Chorus: Amanda Fagan]
Could we go back to how it was back then
When nothing mattered more than friends
Before we lost that happiness
To senselessness and belligerence

[Bridge: Amanda Fagan & Seiggel, ButterscotchBread Mizz Fish & Seiggel, Amanda Fagan, All]
And I'm sorry I didn't become what you wanted
I'm sorry that I left all of your nights haunted
Why is it that you
Always leave in the end
Why is it, with you
Everything's past tense

[Outro: Amanda Fagan]
I still remember
The snow last December
The way it fell on the ground