I wanna make my girl a mixtape
Of love songs she'd know are just from me
But the only songs I know are Christian
So I have to think strategically

Like, when TobyMac said "You consume me,"
I thought of her and how her eyes see through me
And, Switchfoot has an Only Hope
And that's her for me, even though I know

They wrote them for God
For Jesus, for a savior ain't that nice?
But I'm seventeen and I want someone real to hold at night
And I'm terrified, I'm terrified
They'd hate me if they knеw
I'm using worship songs to say I love you

Would they hate mе if they knew?

Well, there's a drag queen out in Tennesee
She dedicates her act to Amy
Well, baby, baby I hope one day she'll be acknowledged
Like, Relient K fucking got my ass through college

But would they hate us if they knew?
Is it hard to be oblivious?
Did you flinch when you threw a little more
Under the bus?
But when the check comes is it glorious?
What's it cost to ignore us?

Maybe I'd hate you if I knew
Maybe I'd hate you if I knew

I wanna make my girl a mixtape
Of love songs she'd know were just from me
But the only songs I know are Christian
So I have to think strategically