[Verse 1]
On a summer day on a hill in New York City
You were lying next to me and you were so pretty
And I told you that I got plans for you and I
So stay with me for the rest of our lives

[Chorus]
Give me one good reason
Why we shouldn't be together
We've been two hearts beating
For a lifetime and forever
So when I ask you
Say yes I do or
Give me one good reason
Just one good reason not to be with you

[Verse 2]
You said you wouldn't leave me, but where did you go?
I've been trying not to lose you, I was unsuccessful
And I told you that I got plans for you and I
So stay with me for the rest of our lives

[Chorus]
Give me one good reason
Why we shouldn't be together
We've been two hearts beating
For a lifetime and forever
So when I ask you
Say yes I do or
Give me one good reason
Just one good reason not to be with you