[Verse 1]
We promised each other we'd end on good terms (After)
No matter what happens, I'll still put you first (After)
After all the love I gave you
Don't you think that I need love too?
If I'm being honest, when you heard my song

[Chorus]
I can't believe you didn't even call
I needed you most and you were gone
Hard to wrap my head around it
Two whole years that never counted
Guess you didn't love me after all
After

[Verse 2]
Christmas vacation with your family (After)
We grew up together, you lived down the street (After)
After all the nights we've been through
After all the promise we'd stay close
If I'm being honest, yeah, when I came home

[Chorus]
I can't believe you didn't even call
I needed you most and you were gone
Hard to wrap my head around it
Two whole years that never counted
Guess you didn't love me after all
After
[Hook]
(All, all) The words you said to me, yeah
(All, all) The lying through your teeth
It’s hard to wrap my head around you
Acting like we never happened
Guess you didn’t love me after all

[Bridge]
Don't know what I expected
Guess it was anything but this
Why'd I get so invested
In someone who doesn’t give a shit?
Oh, oh
If you did, oh
If you did then you would call
After

[Hook]
(All, all) The words you said to me, yeah
(All, all) The lying through your teeth
It’s hard to wrap my head around you
Acting like we never happened
Guess you didn’t love me after all