[Verse 1]
Walking in circles, down the hall
Waiting for the girl he's been crushing on all these years
Patient on his cell phone for that call
Never really happened, so he went to bed and broke down into tears

[Pre-Chorus]
Oh, settle down there. She's out there somewhere...

[Chorus]
Cuddling a new boy, treating him like her own toy
Until he gets rotten. She'll then throw him with the sad boys
Trying to find her a new one, thinking that it's all so fun
Until she's forgotten and treated like the sad boys

[Verse 2]
Whispering a poem at the wall
Pretending it's her cause she made him write all his deepest fears
Acting so gentle like a doll
Down the stairs. She was caught: “honey, it's not what it appears”
But, it's all pretty clear...

[Chorus]
Cuddling a new boy, treating him like her own toy
Until he gets rotten. She'll then throw him with the sad boys
Trying to find her a new one, thinking that it's all so fun
Until she's forgotten and treated like the sad boys
[Bridge]
They left her blue with a sigh
Heartbroken boys left with tears so dry
With nothing else left to say but a tough goodbye

[New Chorus]
Cuddling the new girl, treating her like their own toy
Until she gets rotten. They'll then throw her with the sad boys
Trying to find them a new one, thinking that it's all for fun
Until she's forgotten and treated like the sad boys

[Outro]
Oh, settle down there... tears on her teddy bear