[Verse 1]
Staring at the sun, your arms around my neck
Waves against the rocks, break the silence
But to paint a pretty picture's not what I mean
So rewind it back and read it like a crime scene
Glossy eyes are open
Signs of us struggling
Stones thrown like weapons
Quieted suffering
Can't deny a motive under an ocean of anger and resentment
How could this happen when
I don't wanna be, wanna be, wanna be
With anybody but you

[Chorus]
Took on water until we sank
You and I could'vе lived for an eternity
Hand in hand as wе walk the plank
You and I could've lived for an eternity

[Verse 2]
Stay on the move
Step in the coroner's shoes
Uncovering clues under the light of the moon
They say on the news, killer is still on the loose
But only we knew
Secrets survive in the truth
Never could shut my mouth
Made you uncomfortable
Said it was an accident; made it look intentional
Remedies pleased the moment but we'll never see the morning
I got reservations, I'm afraid of the future we're breaking in
[Chorus]
Took on water until we sank
You and I could've lived for an eternity
Hand in hand as we walk the plank
You and I could've lived for an eternity

[Bridge]
(Hold me one last time)
The dead do not dream but I might as well try
To find you again when the sea meets the sky
The dead do not dream but I might as well try
To find you again when the sea meets the sky

[Chorus]
Took on water until we sank
You and I could've lived for an eternity
Hand in hand as we walk the plank
You and I could've lived for an eternity

I don't wanna be, wanna be, wanna be
With anybody but you

Took on water until we sank
You and I could've lived for an eternity