[Chorus]
I'm nice to you
I'm nice to you, I try for you, I'd die for you
I'm nice to you but you're just not into me
I'm nice to you, I try for you, I'd die for you
I'm nice to you but you're just not into me

[Verse 1]
It's been a long time
Since we sat on the roof and listened to Sondheim
You told me you faked getting wasted at the cast party

I said you're so good at acting
Commitment to feigning drunk takes crafting
Over the top and you'll stop blending in
And

[Pre-Chorus]
Maybe that's where I lost you
Maybe that's what you always do
Pretend that you're into the guy that you're next to
The hook is in deep, you just catch and release

[Chorus]
I'm nice to you
I'm nice to you, I try for you, I'd die for you
I'm nice to you but you're just not into me
I'm nice to you, I try for you, I'd die for you
I'm nice to you but you're just not into me
Whoa, you're just not into me
Whoa - oh, into me
Whoa, you're just not into me
No!
I guess you're my enemy

[Verse 2]
You told me your secrets
I promised I'd cross my heart and die with
Like the time you stole sunscreen
From a Walgreens by the movie theater

Now I'm trying to move on
But my foot's on the gas, with the emergency brake on
Spinning me out, now I'm thinking about the roof and the cast party

[Pre-Chorus]
Well maybe that's where I lost you
And maybe that's what you always do
Pretend that you're into the guy that you're next to
The hook is in deep, you just catch and release

[Chorus]
I'm nice to you
I'm nice to you, I try for you, I'd die for you
I'm nice to you but you're just not into me
I'm nice to you, I try for you, I'd die for you
I'm nice to you but you're just not into me
Whoa, you're just not into me
Whoa - oh, into me
Whoa, you're just not into me
No!
I guess you're my enemy
Enemy, enemy, enemy