[Verse 1]
Amazing fairytale that had come true
A Mr. Reliable Romantic was you
Blinded misguided in the arms of love
Just 'cause it suited the both of us

[Pre-Chorus]
Then it all went wrong
And I'm the one to blame
Taking you for granted in so many ways
And when I look back now
How can I ever forget?
You make me so happy the day we met

[Chorus]
How could something so magic, magic
Become something so tragic, tragic?
Right before my eyes, two separate lives
Every second was a precious moment
Now I'm thinking about the path I've chosen
Wish I could un-make my big mistake
My mistake

[Verse 2]
Communication had broken down
This situation was out of our hands
Well, my hands
You've gotta please understand
That I was too young, yes, just
Too young for that
[Pre-Chorus]
I guess it all went wrong
And I'm the one to blame
But what I would give to have you back again

[Chorus]
How could something so magic, magic
Become something so tragic, tragic?
Right before my eyes, two separate lives
Every second was a precious moment
Now I'm thinking about the path I've chosen
Wish I could un-make my big mistake
My mistake

[Bridge]
The days, the weeks, the months
The years that we have wasted
I'm sorry
I still love you
I don't expect a call 'cause my apology's belated
I'm sorry
And I miss you all my life

[Chorus]
How could something so magic, magic
Become something so tragic, tragic? (Oh, whoa, yeah)
Every second was a precious moment
Now I'm thinking about the path I've chosen (Ooh, ooh-ooh, ooh ooh)
How could something so magic, magic
Become something so tragic, tragic?
Right before my eyes, two separate lives
Every second was a precious moment
Now I'm thinking about the path I've chosen
Wish I could un-make my big mistake
How could something so magic, magic (So magic)
Become something so tragic, tragic? (So tragic, hey, yeah, oh whoa)
Every second was a precious moment (Oh, whoa)
Now I'm thinking about the path I've chosen (Oh whoa, yeah, oh whoa, oh)
How could something so (Oh, whoa)