[Verse 1]
I ran through the garden of evil
Trace your steps, I saw it all
Did he hold your hands the way that you prefer?
And did he ask you like I asked you
Our first time?

[Chorus 1]
Turn the lights off
I don't wanna see myself doing this
I just wanna love you
I just wanna love you
As much as he did

[Verse 2]
I ran through the Garden of Evil
With hastened steps I pull away
Why am I running, if he keeps slowing?
So I hesitate

[Pre-Chorus]
Oh, is this really what you want from me?
(Oh, is this really what you want from me?)
Oh, is this really what you want from me?

[Chorus 1]
Turn the lights off
I don't wanna see myself doing this
I just wanna love you
I just wanna love you
As much as he did
[Post-Chorus]
And maybe this time (I just wanna love you)
We can do it right, so I say (I just wanna love you)
Close your eyes
And maybe this time (I just wanna love you)
We can do it right, so I say (I just wanna love you)
Close your eyes and take your time
Don't be afraid

[Bridge]
I fell into a wishing well
So that's where I've been drinking
Turns out it drove me into the ground
So much for wishful thinking

I fell into a wishing well
So that's where I've been drinking
Turns out it drove me into the ground
So much for wishful thinking

Is this really what you want from me?
(I fell into a wishing well
So that's where I've been drinking)
Oh, is this really what you want from me?
(I fell into a wishing well
So that's where I've been drinking)
[Chorus 2]
Turn the lights on
Pick me up and carry me away from this
I don't want you to love me
I don't want you to love me
Just like they did

[Outro]
And maybe this time
We can do it right, so I say
Close your eyes!
And maybe this time
We can do it right, so I say
Close your eyes and take your time
Don't be afraid