[Verse 1: King Diamond]
In the darkness, after the show
Outside the theater the air is damp and cold
All the people heading for home
They don't believe that what they saw was magic

[Chorus 1: King Diamond]
Oh, it was magic I know
This night was full of it, I never saw the undertow, no
Never saw the evil, never saw the evil
I never saw the evil down below

[Post-Chorus: Livia Zita, King Diamond, Both]
I will never forget that night
I saw the magic in your eyes
We will never forget that night
We saw the magic in each other's eyes

[Guitar Solo: Andy LaRocque]

[Verse 2: King Diamond]
In the darkness, after the show
Outside the theater the air is damp and cold
All the people they are gone
Just you and me and we believe in magic
[Chorus 2: King Diamond]
Oh, it was magic I know
Talking the night away, the things we like are all the same, yeah
Wanna get to know her, wanna get to know her
I gotta get to know her deep down inside

[Guitar Solo: Mike Wead]

[Bridge: King Diamond]
Suddenly, I feel so cold
It feels as if a ghost is next to me
Cold breath in my ear
As it whispers, "Kiss her now"

[Chorus 3: King Diamond]
Oh, it was magic I know
That kiss one year ago, a magic seal of our eternal love
Tonight she went to the theater alone
She never came home and I gotta find her now

[Post-Chorus: Livia Zita, King Diamond, Both]
I will never forget that night
I saw the magic in your eyes
We will never forget that night
We saw the magic in each other's eyes
I will never forget that night
I saw the magic in your eyes
We will never forget that night
We saw the magic in each other's eyes