[Verse 1: Kelsey Grimm]
Walk around with my head down
But I can't hide with these high heels on
Downtown in the thick crowd
But it’s just you that my mind is on
Dressed up, got my heart messed up
You got yours and I got mine
It's unfair that I still care
And I wonder where you are tonight

[Pre-Chorus: Caleb Grimm]
Thinking it could be different, maybe we missed it, yeah
Thinking it could be different
It could, it could

[Chorus: Kelsey Grimm]
It should've been us
Should've been a fire, should've been the perfect storm
It should've been us
Could've been the real thing, now we'll never know for sure, oh
We were crazy, but amazing
Baby, we both know
It should've been us, us
It, it, it should've been us

[Verse 2: Caleb Grimm]
Back and forth like a tug o’ war
What's it all for? Do I want it back?
Still got a little flame for ya
Even though you drove me mad
Now and then, I pretend
That it's you when I close my eyes
You got yoursand I got mine
But I wonder where you are tonight