You look at me so differently
Have I changed so much from who I used to be?
We're both too wise for alibis
We talk but there's so much that we don't say
I guess I've gotten used to it this way

But in Niagara you promised me the moon
And when I fell I couldn't tell it happened all to soon
Up in Niagara we were foolish then
Make it happen again

You hold my hand to please my friends
But when they leave the music stops; the love song ends
And even though I'm reaching out
It feels as though there's nothing coming in
And maybe this is how we've always been

But in Niagara you took me by surprise
I knew you heard my every word just looking in my eyes
Up in Niagara we were crazy then
Make me crazy again

Up in Niagara we were crazy then
Make me crazy again