[Verse 1]
I found myself
Singing in the rain
But I'm singing off-key
I'm not dancing
Just drowning in the pain
No Gene Kelly, not tappin' my feet

[Pre-Chorus 1]
We used to dance through puddles in September
We'd sing our songs, nobody our age remembers

[Chorus]
Our story's not like the classic movies
Doesn't end with you holding me
Won't be getting down on one knee, yeah
This ain't got a happy ending
Cause when the hero comes back
The girl doesn't want him
Fade to black

[Verse 2]
I realized your love was fake
You were lip-syncing for me
But I didn't see it, I didn't hear it
No, no, no, no, no, no
I was too caught up, caught up in the melody
[Pre-Chorus 2]
We used to dance through puddles in September
We'd sing our songs and you said we'd sing them forever

[Chorus]
Our story's not like the classic movies
Doesn't end with you holding me
Won't be getting down on one knee, yeah
This ain't got a happy ending
Cause when the hero comes back
The girl doesn't want him
Fade to black

[Bridge]
I save my tears for a rainy day
Trying to hide my heartbreak
In the drops runnin' down my face
I save my tears for a rainy day
I always thought you'd wait for me
Guess I wasn't worth the wait

[Chorus]
Our story's more like a modern movie
Depressing apathy too close to reality
There's no escape to a happy ending
When I came back you were singing with somebody else
Fade to black
I save my tears for a rainy day
Trying to hide my heartbreak
In the drops runnin' down my face
I save my tears for a rainy day
I always thought you would wait for me
Guess I wasn't worth the wait
I save my tears for a rainy day
I always thought you would wait for me