Songs on this album
- A Soft Place to Land
- Bad Idea
- Bad Idea (Reprise) Drew Gehling
- Club Knocked Up Sara Bareilles
- Dear Baby
- Everything Changes
- I Didn’t Plan It Keala Settle
- I Love You Like a Table Christopher Fitzgerald
- It Only Takes a Taste Drew Gehling
- Never Ever Getting Rid of Me Christopher Fitzgerald
- Opening Up Jessie Mueller, Keala Settle, Kimiko Glenn, Eric Anderson & Waitress Original Broadway Cast Ensemble
- Opening Up (Finale) Original Broadway Cast of Waitress
- She Used to Be Mine
- Take It From An Old Man Sara Bareilles
- The Negative Keala Settle
- What Baking Can Do
- What’s Inside
- When He Sees Me Kimiko Glenn
- You Matter to Me Drew Gehling
- You Will Still Be Mine Nick Cordero