Songs on this album
- A Rumor in St. Petersburg John Bolton
- Close the Door Stephen Flaherty
- Crossing a Bridge
- Everything to Win Derek Klena
- Everything to Win (Reprise)
- Finale Stephen Flaherty
- In a Crowd of Thousands Derek Klena
- In My Dreams
- Journey to the Past Liz Callaway
- Land of Yesterday Stephen Flaherty
- Learn to Do It John Bolton
- Meant to Be John Bolton
- My Petersburg Derek Klena
- Once Upon a December Liz Callaway
- Once Upon a December (Reprise)
- Paris Holds The Key (To Your Heart) John Bolton
- Prologue: Once Upon a December Haley Bennett
- Quartet at the Ballet
- Stay, I Pray You Stephen Flaherty
- Still Ramin Karimloo
- Still / The Neva Flows (Reprise) Ramin Karimloo
- The Countess and the Common Man Stephen Flaherty
- The Neva Flows Ramin Karimloo
- The Press Conference Stephen Flaherty
- We’ll Go from There