Songs on this album
- Act 1 Scene 2: Caring Hands/A Man’s Gotta Do
- Act 1, Scene 1: Horrible Theme/My Freeze Ray/Bad Horse Chorus Neil Patrick Harris
- Act 2 Scene 1: My Eyes
- Act 2 Scene 2: Bad Horse Chorus (Reprise)
- Act 2 Scene 3
- Act 2 Scene 4: Penny’s Song/Brand New Day
- Act 3 Scene 1: So They Say/Everyone’s a Hero/Slipping/Everything You Ever