[Verse 1]
They kept the bar open just for us
So we could talk without being interrupted
And we argued about Regina Spektor
I said I loved her but you think she could be better
Anyways, stop changing the subject
I don't need small talk
Now, I'm upset
Thought we're past the point of talking about nothing just to talk

[Chorus]
'Cause I can't believe it
When you say you love me
I just can't believe it
'Cause with you there's always something
In the back of your mind
Are you done rehearsing lines?
I just can't believe it
But I believe it every fucking time

[Verse 2]
You loved playing drums
In your high school band
God, I saw so many shows
I can't count them on two hands
By the way, I'm playing next Friday
I want you there, but I know you'll miss the train
And you'll show up at the last song
But tell me you were there all along
[Chorus]
And I can't believe it
When you say you love me
I just can't believe it
'Cause with you there's always something
In the back of your mind
Are you done rehearsing lines?
I just can't believe it
But I believe it every fucking time

[Post-Chorus]
Every fucking time
Maybe it's all sincere
And I can't hold back from running when I hear it
Taking steps with a caution sign
Maybe it's all sincere
And I can't hold back from running when I hear it
Taking steps with a caution sign
'Cause I believe it every fucking time