[Verse 1]
Oh, I give up
I've had enough
Of this endless two-player game
I tried too hard
And I didn't get far
The only thing I know is her name

[Verse 2]
What's wrong with me?
Why can't I see
Past her unmistakable eyes?
Her every move
Is something new
Guess I shouldn't wonder why

[Chorus]
I still can't figure out
What she's all about
She's the sweetest misery
She's my favorite mystery
My favorite mystery

[Verse 3]
My tongue is tied
Just about every time
That I thought I knew what to say
And I know, I know she'll never look my way
But I keep trying anyway
[Chorus]
I still can't figure out
What she's all about
She's the sweetest misery
She's my favorite mystery
My favorite mystery

[Bridge]
The way she can't slow down
Her inability to frown
The way she outright beams
Has got a hold on me

[Pre-Chorus]
Oh, what I'd give to solve the mystery
But still I know it's what she'll always be

[Chorus]
I still can't figure out
What she's all about
She's the sweetest misery
She's my favorite mystery
My favorite mystery