[Verse 1: Hugh Dancy]
Never told you
But I meant to
Before I could begin
Even then
I loved you even then

[Chorus 1: Hugh Dancy]
See my heart is
Scared of places
That it's never been
But even then
I loved you even then

[Verse 2: Hugh Dancy]
If my voice should
Start to tremble
If I am shaking
I love you now
Like I loved you even then

[Chorus 2: Lea Michele & Hugh Dancy]
Even if it's uphill now, even when I can't say how
See my heart is scared of places that it’s never been
Even when
My heart won't stop pounding
Even then, even then
I'll keep on even then
I loved you even then
[Chorus 3: Lea Michele & Hugh Dancy]
Even if
It’s uphill now
Even when, there no words how
When my heart pounds this loud
Even then

[Bridge: Megan Hilty]
If I left you
I never meant to
And I won't pretend
Even then
I loved you even then

[Outro: Megan Hilty & Hugh Dancy]
If I just knew
How to show you
Let me try again
I love you even now
Like I loved you even then
Even then, even then