[Verse 1]
I knew you before
Took a lifetime to forget
But as my eyes meet yours
I take all I can get

[Pre-Chorus]
They light up the shadows of my heart
Return stolen works of art
Yet you can't discern this moment's grace

[Chorus]
But I still remember you
In that big, old, white Suburban
And though you look right past me with disregard
The first won't happen twice

[Verse 2]
My gaze shifts to the ground
More alone than I was then
I have searched your eyes
But they don't comprehend

[Pre-Chorus]
I crawl back into the shadows of my heart
And just sit there in the dark
Where you don't requite the love you still take
[Chorus]
But I still remember you
In that big, old, white Suburban
And though you look right past me with disregard
And although I've since moved on
And I've been in love a few times
There's still a piece of me that holds onto you
'Cause the first won't happen twice

[Bridge]
It won't happen twice
It won't happen twice
Oh-oh, hmm, yeah-yeh

[Chorus]
I remember you
In that big, old, white Suburban
And though you look right past me with disregard
And although I've since moved on
And I've been in love a few times
There's still a piece of me that can't let go of you
'Cause the first won't happen twice
Hmmm