[Verse 1]
Was a night in Pensacola
The moon was hanging high
You said you'd reach right up
And pulled it out of the sky
I'm glad it came back

[Verse 2]
You said you had our future
Planned out like a map
We find a little piece of heaven
No matter where we're at
It's gone just like that

[Chorus]
Indian giver, you give and you take
Indian giver, took your love away
And handed it to her
You Indian giver

[Verse 3]
Might only take a moment
But you'll take your precious time
To steal her innocence
The way you stole mine
The way you stole mine
[Chorus]
Indian giver, you give and you take
Indian giver, took your love away
And handed it to her
You Indian giver

[Bridge]
Bet you got 'em lined up like a train
And you could sell the sun even when it rains
You needn't take that away
Indian giver, you give and you take

[Chorus]
Indian giver, you give and you take
Indian giver, you took your love away
And handed it to her
Yeah, you handed it to her
You Indian giver
Indian giver