[Verse 1: Gabi]
Dear girl, whoever you are
It's me, the one from the start
He's yours, don't care at all
He'll break you, I'll watch you fall
You're great, but I am too
This isn't shade, I'm with someone new
You didn't win, we went separate ways
But one time, I was his everything

[Chorus: Both]
Everything he says to you, he said to me first, first
First, first
Everything he's done to you, everything he feels with you
Everything he has with you, he had with me
First, first, first, first
First, first, first, first
Everything he's done to you, everything he feels with you
Everything he has with you, he had with me, first

[Verse 2: Niki]
Time's gone and so is he (And so is he)
I'm not the one with jealousy (With jealousy)
I'm great I'm doing fine (I'm doing fine)
Happier than I've been in my life
These are things you need to know (You need to know)
So you can stop your little show (Your little show)
First love, first fling
What you have, don't change our thing
[Chorus: Both & Blaise Delfino]
Everything he says to you, he said to me
First, first, first, first
Everything he's done to you, everything he feels with you
Everything he has with you, he had with me
First, first, first, first
First, first, first, first
Everything he's done to you, everything he feels with you (Yeah)
Everything he has with you (Blaise D, check it), he had with me, first

[Bridge: Blaise Delfino]
Yeah, 'cause in my mind I've got these memories
I hope that you remember me
I'm sorry but I had to leave you alone in the cold
Used to call me on the cellphone when he wasn't home
Yeah, and now that's in the past I'm thinking back
To what we had all the laughs
Never thought that this love would crash
So I checked out, packed up, and drove down
This lonely road I'm sorry but I had to let you go, yup
I got a new girl, forgot about you, girl
Don't wanna throw shade but I changed my ways for you girl
Sittin', waitin', wishin' for the one that I care for
The one I'd be there for, the one that could count
4, 3, 2, she's the 1
Never thought I'd be the type of guy to fall in love
But I trusted, I trust in her
And love hurts, I loved her, but I never loved you
[Chorus: Both]
Everything he says to you, he said to me
First, first, first, first
Everything he's done to you, everything he feels with you
Everything he has with you, he had with me
First, first, first, first
First, first, first, first
Everything he's done to you, everything he feels with you
Everything he has with you, he had with me, first