[Verse 1]
Pretty boy with your kiddy smile and then your eyes so green
Boy, it drives me wild with your cold skin
And your voice float tender, oh
That sweet southern man
One beat up like a music box
Let me play as you begin to rock me
Back and forth, like a baby
'Cause I used to be your baby

[Chorus]
If you would've kept me, we'd be
Sitting by the pond, drinkin' Cherry Pepsi
Talkin' 'bout how you wanna get married
You're a selfish boy, and your heart is buried
Why? Why'd you have to do this to me?
Why'd you have to kill me? Oh, pretty boy

[Verse 2]
Pretty boy with your spider hands
Crawling on me as I play the grand piano
And I sing you a song 'cause you
You said my voice really turns you on
And propositions bring so much tension
It's all about love until you voice your opinion
Give me yours, and I gave you mine
But you never paid attention
[Chorus]
If you would've kept me, we'd be
Sitting by the pond, drinkin' Cherry Pepsi
Talkin' 'bout how you wanna get married
You're a selfish boy, and your heart is buried
Why? Why'd you have to do this to me?
Why'd you have to kill me? Oh, pretty boy

[Bridge]
And you only lit my cigarette
So you could smoke it too
You quit so you could heal me
You said your credit was due
And I guess I couldn't have
What I always thought was mine
Yeah, I guess I couldn't have
What I always thought was mine

[Chorus]
If you would've kept me, we'd be
Sitting by the pond, drinkin' Cherry Pepsi
Talkin' 'bout how you wanna get married
You're a selfish boy, and your heart is buried
Why? Why'd you have to do this to me?
Why'd you have to kill me? Oh, pretty boy