[Verse 1]
Honestly
It all happened pretty fast
And by the month, you said you loved me, and I said it back
We were convinced
There's no way we wouldn't last
Then we drove the whole thing to the ground and watched it crash

[Chorus]
What if you saw me like the first time, saw me like the first time?
You said your heart came out of your chest now, don't lie
Can't help but think your head is off and movin' on, oh-oh
Or worse, that first time look, that first time look wore off

[Verse 2]
Last July
Wish I could've seen behind your eyеs
You told me that I was the most beautiful girl alivе
Now every word
That I say must strike a nerve
How 'bout the girl you met last year? Would you say that to her?

[Chorus]
What if you saw me like the first time, saw me like the first time?
You said your heart came out of your chest now, don't lie
Can't help but think your head is off and movin' on, oh-oh
Or worse, that first time look, that first time look wore off
[Post-Chorus]
Ooh-ooh, ooh-ooh
That first time look wore off
Ooh-ooh, ooh-ooh (Oh-oh)

[Bridge]
Used to care what I said and now you're not listenin'
Oh, I'm scared what'd you say to your friends?
Paragraphs that you'd send turned to one word answerin'
No, you wouldn't dare to do that then, ooh

[Chorus]
What if you saw me like the first time, saw me like the first time?
You said your heart came out of your chest now, don't lie
Can't help but think your head is off and movin' on, oh-oh (Ooh)
Or worse (Or worse), that first time look, that first time look wore off

[Post-Chorus]
Ooh-ooh, ooh-ooh
That first time look wore off
Ooh-ooh, ooh-ooh (Just wore off; Oh-oh)