[Verse 1]
Was it my fault the cup went cold?
We were too young to feel this old
Too much sugar and not enough cream
To keep on living in this fairy tale dream
Was it my fault the sky turned gray?
We were too free to feel this way
Pinch of black, a pinch of white
We tried too hard to get it right

[Chorus]
Is my fault that time stands still?
Did I stay stuck against my will?
Too much thought
A lot of it gone to keep myself from moving on
Was it my fault that time stands still?

[Verse 2]
Was it my fault we lost the glow?
We were too high to feel this low
Too much time exchangin' or spent
Words were heard, but were not meant
Was it my fault the house fell down?
You held my hands but let us drown?
Looked for help and you found scars
We're so close but yet so far
[Chorus]
Is my fault that time stands still?
Did I stay stuck against my will?
Too much thought
A lot of it gone to keep myself from moving on
Was it my fault that time stands still?

[Outro]
Is it my fault the sun comes up?
A bitter taste in a lonely cup
A lot less color, a lot less light
We could never get it right