[Verse 1]
Call you up on Tuesday
Say, "What's up?" Babe, it's too late
Why'd you have to be so complicated?
Complicated

[Chorus]
'Cause I'm not sure if I've seen you before
You looked familiar when I saw you
We go together like the gum on my shoes
We make out, we make out when it's too late
We go out, we go out on a Tuesday

[Verse 2]
A crowded place, waiting for you
Am I lost, why can't I find you?
A silhouette that's in my head
You don't exist, you're my imagination
You don't exist, you're just a bad decision

[Chorus]
'Cause I'm not sure if I've seen you before
You looked familiar when I saw you
We go together like the gum on my shoes
We make out, we make out when it's too late
We go out, we go out on a Tuesday
[Instrumental Break]

[Chorus]
'Cause I'm not sure if I've seen you before
You looked familiar when I saw you
We go together like the gum on my shoes
We make out, we make out when it's too late
We go out, we go out on a Tuesday, yeah

[Instrumental Break]

[Spoken Outro]
Woah
Hello again
Just me and you, hey
This is crazy for me
I don't think I can explain it enough
Um, thank you so much for coming
Um, this is the song that pretty much started it all, really
Um, here's "Coffee"