[Verse 1: Matt Brandyberry]
It's stuck on repeat, making me breathe ever so deeply inside
Am I sleeping? I've tried screaming, nothing can keep me alive
It seems easy, make-believing, leaving these feelings behind
It's deceiving, guaranteeing, nothing is seemingly right

[Pre-Chorus: Branden Kreider & Matt Brandyberry]
Can't look away, can't bare to watch but want to see
I can't escape this flood that I jumped in
Without a trace, I vanish from the air I breathe
Last gasp I take, I thought nothing was something

[Chorus: Chris Musser]
The best thing to ever happened to me
Has now become the worst thing
It’s still the same old story
Still the same old story

[Verse 2: Matt Brandyberry]
It still replays all of these days, all of these ways that it died
Paths that we made left to decay, all from betrayal and pride
Feels like D-Day when we stay like cars on freeways that collide
Let's be safe and not retrace mistakes that we made throughout time

[Pre-Chorus: Branden Kreider & Matt Brandyberry]
Can't look away, can't bare to watch but want to see
I can't escape this flood that I jumped in
Without a trace, I vanish from the air I breathe
Last gasp I take, I thought nothing was something
[Chorus: Chris Musser]
The best thing to ever happened to me
Has now become the worst thing
It’s still the same old story
Still the same old story

[Bridge: Chris Musser]
If I make it out alive
I'll make it my last goodbye
I'll make it my last goodbye

[Chorus: Chris Musser]
The best thing to ever happened to me
Has now become the worst thing
It’s still the same old story
Still the same old story

[Chorus: Chris Musser & Branden Kreider]
If I make it out alive
I’ll make it my last goodbye
Still the same old, same old
Still the same old story
Still the same old, same old
Still the same old story