[Verse 1]
She used to love me once upon a time
Back when my life was a dream
Diamonds and doobies and old western movies
We made one hell of a scene
She had a smile like a Montana sky
A laugh like a song in my ear
But that was the old her before I broke her
I put the cry in her tear

[Chorus]
God made her the right way, hell, that much I'm sure of
But she turned the wrong way when she wanted more of
A man that's forsaken and ain't worthy of her love
Now she's a long gone highway
And I know I made her that way

[Verse 2]
I made her mine on a night in October
Damn, man, that didn't last long
'Cause I made her regret all the nights she spent
With nothing but wine to keep warm
Now she don't have no heart to give to another
'Cause I broke the one that God gave
And she don't trust no one 'cause the last one was no fun
And I know I made her that way
[Chorus]
But God made her the right way, hell, that much I'm sure of
But she turned the wrong way when she wanted more of
A man that's forsaken and ain't worthy of her love
Now she's a long gone highway
And I know I made her that way

[Chorus]
God made her the right way, hell, that much I'm sure of
But she turned the wrong way when she wanted more of
A man that's forsaken and ain't worthy of her love
Now she's a long gone highway
And I'm the fool who's to blame
'Cause I made her that way

[Outro]
She used to love me once upon a time